I'm by no means a pro! From what I have read, 12 to 14 three watt CREE's is about the same light output as a 250watt MH. I think if you went with a little longer heat sink and the same amount of LED's you would be just fine. For your optics I think I would go with 80 degree's since your tank isn't that deep and it's wider. I don't know how long your tank is so I can't say how many fixtures I would use. Remember I'm no expert! I just spent the last year deployed in Iraq and did a lot of research and read about LED's. I still have yet to know whether I made the right choice going with LED's since My tank and lights are not finnished.